Showing posts with label smart people. Show all posts
Showing posts with label smart people. Show all posts

Monday, December 15, 2025

NEW version of the Famous Whitepaper Requirements for Secure Control and Telecommunication Systems

The Austrian, German, and Swiss Utilities have published (with the support of Dr. Stephan Beirer and Marl Joos (GAI NetConsult GmbH, Berlin/Germany)) the Version 3.0 of the famous 

Whitepaper Requirements for Secure Control and Telecommunication Systems

The English version (pdf, 88 pages) could be downloaded HERE.

Die deutsche Version (pdf, 92 Seiten) kann HIER heruntergeladen werden.

It is highly recommended to read, understand, and implement the recommendations! They reflect the latest experiences and need in our highly interconnected electric power world!

Today I will focus on two issues: the first is discussed in the Whitepaper, the second is discussed in a paper from AXPRO in Switzerland.

The Whitepaper says on page 46 (bzw Seite 47 in der deutschen Version):

"In line with the given technical capabilities, standardised IEC protocols should be used across the board. The private range of these communication protocols should only be used where necessary for technological reasons. Without additional measures, the standard protocols IEC 60870-5-101/104 and IEC 61850 offer no secure integrity protection, authentication or encryption. In such cases, the available extensions according to IEC 62351 should be used. Potential limitations, e.g. in terms of performance and error diagnostics as well as the necessary key management infrastructure and processes should be considered.

For communication across zone boundaries, protocol breaks should be provided, e.g. through application layer gateways or by converting to a different protocol, to reduce potential vulnerabilities and weak points."

I fully agree with this last sentence. This brings me to the second issue: 

The Swiss utility AXPRO published a great paper with the title: OT-Security im Unterwerk  ... means in substations ... the paper is in English. You can download it HERE.

On page 3 you can find this:

Geräte diversifizieren

"Die klassischen Ansätze der Literatur geben einen Überblick über Lösungen. Dies beginnt bei gängigen Konzepten zur Ersatzteilhaltung und setzt sich bei der technischen Redundanz von Komponenten fort. Die zusätzlichen Komponenten halten den Betrieb bei einem Ausfall aufrecht – zumindest einen Minimalbetrieb. Die eingesetzten Geräte und Systeme können zudem mit unter-schiedlichen Komponenten diversifiziert werden, beispielsweise durch Geräte unterschiedlicher Hersteller, Gerätefamilien mit signifikanten Unterschieden sowie Kommunikationsvarianten. Eine einzelne Schwachstelle kann somit nie die Funktion des Gesamtsystems gefährden. Die Diversität stellt eine Hürde dar, die ein Angreifer überwinden muss. Allerdings muss auch beachtet und akzeptiert werden, dass durch eine grössere Diversität ein Mehraufwand für den Betrieb und somit zusätzliche Kosten entstehen."

They are obviously following the recommendation of the Whitepaper!! Thanks. The statement in the last sentence is important to understand: The implementation and application of many security measures needs peopleware and reasonable budgets!

I have discussed peopleware many times for years ... it seems to be more important than ever ... see also my latest discussion on people ...

Be aware: The most secure communication is the one that is not implemented or implemented but not in use!



Thursday, July 11, 2019

Holistic Engineering and IEC Standards


One of the most crucial challenges in Electric Power Systems in the future is the fact that multiple aspects like planning, design, configuration, data acquisition, operation, protection, error detection, maintenance, ... security, ... at several layers (process, asset management, ...) are so co-joined with each other and interdependent.

Is this new? No! Some 400 years (!) ago, Rene Descartes was recommending to apply a holistic approach for all sciences ... he did not know the huge interconnected Power systems in Europe, China, USA, ... here is what he has written [extended by myself]:



I highly recommend to educate young people in a way that they get a holistic understanding of the many aspects of the electric power system ... focusing on one or two aspects may cause at the end of the day many problems. The main aspect still is to understand the physics of such a huge system. Any programmer of software impacting the safety of the power delivery system should be educated in physics and especially electrical systems. So, understanding MMS, IEC 61850 or OPC UA is good - BUT engineers should understand the process (electrical system) they are manipulating with some lines of code. Engineers should also be trained thoroughly in the many aspects.

Unfortunately there is quite often little budget for comprehensive training in several aspects. Ask your management for more training - better:more hands-on training!!

Thursday, July 7, 2016

Should Power Grids Put Their Critical Digital Systems Off?

Power delivery systems worldwide are under heavy stress: physical stress and stress caused by shareholders and hackers and ... The stress is heavy often due to very limited resources that hinder engineers to improve the system very much.

Some people believe that the solution may be lying in going back to the Old Days! They want to spend USD 10.000.000+ for studying to go ,Back to analog and non-digital control systems, purpose-built control systems, and physical controls. Who has said this? ... some 20 years ago? No: this month!

The motto of some US congress man seems to be: Get rid of state-of-the-art technology.

A corresponding bill was assigned to a congressional committee on June 6, 2016:
Click HERE for more details.
Click HERE to download the text of the bill [pdf].

Click HERE for a discussion published under nextgov.com.

Does this mean the end of digital protection and automation systems? The end of communication according to IEC 61850, IEC 60870-5, DNP3, Modbus, ...?

What is needed? More well educated engineers that can use the digital technology in a way that the power delivery system can be managed securely and that become able to understand how the technology can be applied in order to re-start the power delivery system after a blackout.

I would like to see 10 per cent of the budget (USD 1.000.000) spent into education for protection, automation, SCADA and communications engineers. Have you ever tried to get approval for attending a training course for advanced protection, automation, SCADA, and communications like IEC 61850, or ...??

My experience after I run more than 230 courses worldwide and educated more than 4.100 engineers is this: many engineers that have asked me for a quote to conduct an in-house course or attending a public course had to give up due to budget restrictions!!

The other USD 10.000.000 could be spent for improving the digital based equipment as Cris Thomas, a security expert (see link to nextgov.com above), said: "Instead of spending two years and $10 million exploring ways to downgrade critical systems with even more outdated tech, we should instead invest that time and money into transforming security for the technology currently in place, and into building next-generation security features directly into future technology."

If utilities want to change the way the run their assets the management and stake holders should listen to the engineers!! And follow their recommendations! This is even more crucial in case of implementing more physical control done by human beings!

Badly educated engineers could do more harm than well operating machines.

Whatever we want to do to "ruggedize" our power delivery system, we need more well educated and experienced engineers. Retiring senior engineers with 52 years (to reduce costs) is not a real option! Or? We need you all! And we need young people to study electric power systems and information technology.

Click HERE for some additional discussion by myself (German version).



Tuesday, March 22, 2016

Ukrainian Power Grid -- Cyber Attack is a Wake-Up Call for All of us

"On December 23, 2015, the Ukrainian Kyivoblenergo, a regional electricity distribution company, reported service outages due to a third party’s illegal entry into the company’s computer and SCADA systems. ... the strongest capability of the attackers was not in their choice of tools or in their expertise, but in their capability to perform long‐term reconnaissance operations required to learn the environment and execute a highly synchronized, multistage, multisite attack. ..."

Click HERE for an interesting Report that provides "important details surrounding the attack, offering lessons learned, and recommending approaches to help the ICS community repel similar attacks."
This and other attacks are Wake-Up Calls for Everybody! We should be aware that to some extent this trend will impact us all one way or the other - sooner or later.
One thing is sure: The future secure delivery of electric power will require more resources and smart people!!

Monday, February 22, 2016

Training in Montreal (Canada): Mastering the complexity of IEC 61850

OPAL-RT TECHNOLOGIES invites you to the very crucial Training:
Mastering the complexity of IEC 61850
Adoption of the IEC 61850 standard in North America is slowly emerging for Transmission and Distribution markets, but an increasing number of implementations is expected, either through new installations or following cost-benefit assessments in modernization projects. Now is a good time to get in touch with the state-of-the-art technologies and standard that will guide present and future SAS design.
During this seminar, truly experienced, vendor independent engineers will help you see and understand how to use the core parts of the IEC 61850 standard applied in substation design, monitoring, protection and control applications. You will learn from senior protection engineers, how the protection system will improve and understand the crucial lessons learned since the first projects with IEC 61850 in 2004, all through interactive training, live demos and hands-on exercises.
Monday, 25 April 2016 at 9:00 AM - Friday, 29 April 2016 at 5:00 PM (EDT)
Le Nordelec - 1751 rue Richardson, Suite 4312 Montréal, QC H3K 1G6 CA
Click HERE for more details and registration information.
See you there.

Wednesday, May 13, 2015

Just started: Grid 3.0

Have you heard about “Grid 3.0”? This seems to be the next phase of the power delivery system. Recently several U.S. organizations have discussed the future of the power delivery system. According to their view there are 3 phases so far:

  • “Grid 1.0” can be thought of as the legacy grid of the 20th century
  • “Grid 2.0” is the emergence of the smart grid with automation and information technology improvements, and
  • “Grid 3.0” is what comes next: for example, a future grid with advanced grid operations and greater interactions with consumers and other infrastructures.

Click HERE to access a list of presentations from the

Grid 3.0 Workshop
March 26 to March 27
at NIST, Gaithersburg, MD

Click HERE for a workshop summary.

We are currently in all three phases at the same time. Most of the systems are still legacy (for the next 20+ years), a few start to use automation and information technology, and some start to think about the future … power engineers have always thought about the future (even 130 years ago). One of the big issues in Grid 2.0 and Grid 3.0 is the need for interoperable of systems. We can reach a high level of interoperability – if we want! This is less a technical issue. It all depends on decisions to be made by humans. If we decide to get it, we can get it. Some may not like interoperability at all. Or?

Anyway, let’s assume we get there: Would we then generate Data Tsunamis all over? It is likely that people start to push every data into the cloud – expecting that somebody may use it.

Make sure that you understand your needs – before you look for a protocol or a data model. We have a single protocol for most near-real-time data (IEC 61850-8-1) and data models for almost everything. But does everybody need everything? No!

The big question is: What do you need? To answer this: You need to understand your application.

Friday, May 8, 2015

Are You Looking for IEC 61850 Related Publications?

Here is a very interesting link to a database (GetInfo - The Portal for Science and Technology) that lists some 830 publications related to IEC 61850. You can search for authors and contributors.

image

Click HERE for a search on “IEC 61850”.

Saturday, April 11, 2015

IEC 61850 at the Hannover Messe 2015

Products and Services regarding IEC 61850, IEC 60870-5-104 and other standards can be seen in action, e.g., at these booths:

SystemCorp, Perth, Australia
Booth C35/4 in Hall 13

Click HERE for details and a free entrance Ticket.

Beck IPC, Wetzlar, Germany
Booth C35/5 in Hall 13

Click HERE  for details and a free entrance ticket.

HMS Industrial Networks, Halmstad, Sweden
Booth D35 in Hall 8

Clicke HERE for details and a free entrance ticket.

Wednesday, December 17, 2014

IEC Smart Grid Standards Map

IEC has spent some time to list the relevant standards for the many areas of Smart(er) Grids:

http://smartgridstandardsmap.com/

When you browse this site, you may wonder to see a list of 301 standards and other official specifications. There are many areas that are related to the 50 Hz or 60 Hz 3-phase electrical power systems:

  • Advanced distribution management system
  • Advanced metering infrastructure
  • Asset management and condition monitoring system
  • Blackout prevention system
  • Clock reference system
  • Communication network
  • Communication network management system
  • Data modelling
  • Demand response / Load management
  • Distributed energy resources operation system
  • Distribution automation system
  • E-mobility system
  • EMC & Power quality
  • Electric Storage system
  • Energy management system
  • FACTS for grids
  • Generation management system
  • Industrial automation system
  • Market place systems
  • Meter-related back-office systems
  • Security
  • Smart home and building automation system
  • Substation automation system
  • Weather forecast

The home page states: “Easily and instantly identify the standards that are needed for any part of the Smart Grid – no need to be a standards expert”. Hm, really? There may be no need to be an expert browsing the site – BUT if you are not an expert in standards like IEC 60870-5-10x, CIM, IEC 61400-25, IEC 61850,  IEC 62351, … then you need to talk an EXPERT. We are here to help you!

Fortunately, when it comes to information exchange, the many parts of IEC 61850 are the most crucial standards you will find in the list of the 301 standards:

IEC 61850-6
IEC 61850-7-1 
IEC 61850-7-2
IEC 61850-7-3
IEC 61850-7-4
IEC 61850-7-410
IEC 61850-7-420
IEC 61850-8-1
IEC 61850-8-2
IEC 61850-80-1
IEC 61850-80-4
IEC 61850-9-2
IEC 61850-90-1
IEC 61850-90-10
IEC 61850-90-11
IEC 61850-90-12
IEC 61850-90-13
IEC 61850-90-14
IEC 61850-90-15
IEC 61850-90-2
IEC 61850-90-3
IEC 61850-90-4
IEC 61850-90-5
IEC 61850-90-6
IEC 61850-90-7
IEC 61850-90-8
IEC 61850-90-9

I guess, even IEC has not fully understood the impact of IEC 61850 on the power delivery system: So, why is IEC 61850-90-3 missing in the list of standards relevant for cable?

image

Here is an overview (from draft IEC 61850-90-3) on cable monitoring:

image

It is impossible to list IEC 61850 in any application domain. The model (LN – Logical Node) STMP (temperature supervision) could be used allover – where ever a temperature is measured. Modeling the temperature in a green house and communication the value with IEC 61850 does not require to list IEC 61850 as a standard for green houses … ;-)

IEC 61850 is a common standard that covers specific and general models and services.

To understand the impact of IEC 61850: you have to be an expert or you have to ask an expert.

Saturday, August 2, 2014

Do You Really Want to Use Your Phone for Remote Control?

Kim Zetter reported on 31 July that “Hackers Can Control Your Phone Using a
Tool That’s Already Built Into It”.

Would you like to be controlled by somebody else? Somebody you don’t know?

The report starts: “ … Two researchers have uncovered such built-in vulnerabilities in a large number of smartphones that would allow government spies and sophisticated hackers to install malicious code and take control of the device.”

Click HERE for the full report.

I hope that you are not planning to use smart phones in any critical infrastructure! Be smart! Any remote control in the energy automation could be very dangerous. Automation systems that highly depend on control commands from a central unit are in danger to be hacked or compromised by errors – independent of smart phones.

We have to thing towards more autonomous automation. Inputs to remote stations may be limited mainly to set-points that allow the algorithms in the remote units to check against the physical measurements and other information (situational awareness).

Wednesday, June 4, 2014

MegaWatt Needs Smarter Megabit/s

What do we need? Huge countries need many MWatt (unit of power) to survive. To get the power whenever we want to use it, we need more “Smart Mbit/s” (“smart” data transfer rate in Mega bit per second). That means: more communicating devices … maybe tens of Millions in some time down the road. What do 1,000 MegaWatt (= 1 GW) and 1,000 Mbit/s (= 1 Gbit/s) have in common? These are huge numbers! And more: We need them both in the near future! The crucial issue is here: One needs the other. Zero GW means Zero Gbit/s and Zero Gbit/s means Zero GW.

Yes, you got it! The two are becoming increasingly interdependent!

There is (mainly) ONE medium to carry power: wires. There are hundreds or even thousands of media to communicate information! Guess you could not count them all. In order to keep the cost for the future power delivery system reasonably low, we could and should think of preventing the proliferation of communication systems. Guess you agree. But: Which solutions are worth to use? No doubt: IEC 61850, IEC 60870-5-104, DNP3, Modbus, … are those that would do a good job!

I would be very happy to have as many communication systems as we have power delivery systems: DC 24V, DC 48V, 3 phase AC 110V/60Hz, 3 phase AC 240V/50 Hz, … and a few more.

Clark Gellings (one of the world’s leading experts on the electricity system, ERPI Palo Alto) talked in a podcast about “The Future of the Power Grid”. He talks about crucial aspects of the future power systems. Key issues (from my point of view) are summarized in the following three points:

Question:
“So what are a few of the things that will have to happen between now and 50 years from now to make your vision of the grid a reality?

Clark Gellings’ answer:
Well, first, we’re going to need communications standards that allow devices to talk to one another, so that we don’t have the problem we have now. For example, in buildings, the electronics that are being used have as many as 28 different communications architectures. And so one building technology that might control some new thermal storage unit you have may not be able to talk to another device in that building.

Number two, the computer system that would control these millions of nodes in any given region of the United States, they don’t exist. I mean, we can control tens of thousands of nodes, and we do now, but we’re going to need to control millions of nodes. So that’s another area of development.

And thirdly, technology. For example, power electronics to fully be able to control, in a very fluid way, the power systems, even to the point of doing things like having the system self-heal, or taking action so as to mitigate from an outage that it sees, even before necessarily the outage has occurred.”

… sounds very expensive!? Not that much … listen to Clark Gellings.

Click HERE to listen to the podcast, find a link to download the mp3, and read the content.

Anyway, the 28 different communication architectures in the building automation he mentions are not so bad - compared to the factory automation with hundreds of solutions!

image

why not use the IEC 61158 (solutions)? Because it has too many!

image

IEC 61850 is about to unify most of them (at least at the near-process level where we find the Millions of signals to be shared between Millions of smart devices). And to provide smarter mechanisms to share information.

I hope we can convert more Mbit/s into “Smart Mbit/s”: using them in a smart way. Using smart communication mechanisms (like IEC 61850) will require less bandwidth and smart power systems will need less MW.

Friday, May 30, 2014

Exhibition in Paris: SG Paris 2014 - From Smart Grids to Smart Networks, June 11-13

You are invited to stop at booth i4 at the SG Paris 2014 - From Smart Grids to Smart Networks, and see IEC 61850, IEC 60870-5-104 and Gateways in action:

com.tom -Smart Grid solution

The Exhibition & Conference start from June 11 to 13 in La Défense (Paris) – daily from 8:30h – 19:00h).

In France, Smart Grid technologies have been rapidly developing over the course of the past few years, with high stakes surrounding the roll-out of smart meters, and notably ERDF's highly publicized meter, Linky, and GRDF's Gazpar.

The Smart Grids Paris trade show is now one of Europe's leading events in the Smart Grids field, counting 3000 attendees, 70 exhibitors and almost 150 speakers.

Beck IPC, EBDS and NettedAutomation invite you to visit us at the SG Paris 2014 at the booth of EBDS (European Business Development Services) i4 and see our standard-based solutions for smart grids:

  • com.tom data manager with an integrated service router, switching functionality, various modems, and live data connection to the com.tom internet portal system.
  • IEC 61850, IEC 61400-25, IEC 60870-5-104, and IEC 62351 (security) are integrated to easily build gateways and manage your data.
  • Everything you are looking for - integrated in a single device!
  • Applications: Data Concentrator, System Monitoring, Asset Monitoring, Gateway, RTU, Interface to any process level devices, sensors and actuators, …
  • Examples of applications:

Access to the exhibition is free.

More about com.tom under www.com-tom.de
More about the fair under www.sgparis.fr

See you there.

Saturday, February 8, 2014

ABB: “Smart Planning” by “Consultancy Light”

Many advanced technologies for managing electric power delivery systems are implemented for high voltage transmission systems operated by big utilities. The smaller utilities (mainly distribution system operators) usually just follow the “rules” set by the big utilities. To this end: the power and the technology are “flowing top-down”.

The power is now flowing “top-down” and “bottom-up”. The technology needed in the future power system automation requires more than just “copying” the technologies from the big utilities. May requirements are very unique to the power delivery automation – the tools and approaches to keep the power reliably flowing at distribution level are under high pressure.

ABB has started a new group in Germany to offer a three step “Smart Planning” to meet the new challenges in distribution networks:

1. Classification of a distribution network
2. If the load limits are almost reached, the network monitoring phase starts
3. Voltage control and other technologies (e.g., smart Transformers) are considered

This prevents to start with expensive and detailed network calculations as applied in high voltage transmission systems.

Click HERE for the ABB press release on “Smart Planning” [PDF, German, 12 KB].

This “Smart Planning” requires a huge amount of new process measurements (3 phase voltage and current, temperature, power quality measurements, etc) and calculated values. IEC 61850 has the right “smart” international solution that backs this new planning approach.

Get all your data engineered,configured and communicated with IEC 61850. Start now with the basic information shared between the process and the applications to feed control, protection and optimization software with “smart” information. Prevent exchanging tons of data – look for useful and crucial information and not for data. Prevent flooding your control center with useless data flowing “bottom-up” – distributed control will extend the centralized systems of today. It is a combination of centralized and de-centralized monitoring and control that will keep the system stable.

Cooperate with “smart people” to get “smart”" power distribution systems”.

Click on the following links if you want to learn how to get there:

TÜV SÜD Seminars [DE], NettedAutomation hands-on Training [EN], Beck IPC Workshop [EN, DE]

The future of power distribution networks needs Teamwork – to make the Dream work … the dream of a sustainable power system. This team is more than just the experts of a huge manufacturer. Utility experts and consultants need to work together with the vendors’ experts.

Friday, January 31, 2014

Draft Version 3.0 of NIST Smart Grid Framework

NIST just published the draft version of the “NIST Framework and Roadmap for Smart Grid Interoperability Standards, Release 3.0” and asks for review.

Click HERE to visit the page with the link to download the draft [pdf, 6.4 MB]

The standard series IEC 61850 is a very crucial standard referred to throughout the document!

Check also the SGIP Catalog of Standards Information Library.

Saturday, January 18, 2014

Is IEC 61850 creating Opportunities for a Revolution?

Don’t ask for it – you may get it!

I read the other day a paper on IEC 61850 (written by known experts) that summarizes in the opening sentence: “IEC 61850 is an approved international standard for communications in substations that is creating opportunities for a revolution in the world of electric power systems protection and control.”

According to Wikipedia “A revolution (from the Latin revolutio, "a turn around") is a fundamental change in power or organizational structures that takes place in a relatively short period of time.”

The core parts of the standard have been published some 10 years ago. The crucial underlying technology is even older. I have not yet seen many opportunities for a revolution in the communication – yes, some new communication possibilities have been implemented. The introduction of the standard is more a marathon than a sprint! There are very good new features related to engineering and configuration (SCL) – their application will even take much longer then the use of Ethernet, TCP/IP, MMS, ACSI, … Anyway, the standard communication defined in IEC 61850-7-2 and –8-1 are excellent.

Let’s have a look on the communication “revolution”. The first figure depicts a very traditional way to exchange status changes, measurements and calculated analogue values, counted values, and so on: The destination (master or client) sends request messages to the source (slave, server) and receives the requested values. The request may be sent cyclically or at any time. The rate of these request-response transactions (controlled by the caller) has a crucial impact on the bandwidth use and real-time behavior.

image

Depending on the needs there could be a huge difference in sending requests more or less often. Read some hints on reporting versus polling.

Now let’s have a look at the telecontrol protocols IEC 60870-5-104 and DNP3 (as well known and used examples). They offer additional possibilities: receiving cyclic reports from the source, receiving event driven reports (!) and cyclic reports of analogue values initiated by the source.

image

Finally we check the standard communication defined in IEC 61850. IEC 61850 offers all the above discussed possibilities – it has some optimization build in: DataSets (referring to a list of values). The crucial add-on is the GOOSE messaging and Sampled Value exchange:

image

GOOSE is a combination of event-driven information exchange (event will be sent immediately) and cyclic transmission (event will be repeated immediately, a little bit later, … any finally in a long cycle). Sampled values comprise an exchange of values that are taken in a time-synchronized fashion. The communication does not need to transmit cyclically – the values taken at the same instance of time are used for calculation.

So, the most crucial new communication services defined in IEC 61850 are GOOSE and Sampled Values – and the possibility to configure the behavior of reporting, GOOSE and sampled values through SCL and by online services.

There is one additional service in IEC 61850 that is quite new: Logging.

In many applications where IEC 61850 is used we see more of a slow evolution – not a revolution. I guess the power industry can not easily be revolutionized. That is a good situation – without that we would have to sit more often in the dark.

Smart Grids is a 19th century invention. The evolution that happened during this very long period of time is what has brought us today’s secure and safe electric power delivery. Note: Haste produces Waste! Take your time … and use IEC 61850 when it’s time to do so … not earlier! The evolution has to start in the heads by good education provided by people that understand that utilities don’t want to get a revolution at all.

I hope we will not get a revolution!

Sunday, October 20, 2013

Open positions in the US related to IEC 61850

It seems that there is a growing interest in applying IEC 61850 in the United States. At least there are tenth of open positions that require knowledge and experience in IEC 61850.

One states for example: “Experience with IEC 61850 compliant substation automation applications including IED configuration utilizing MMS and GOOSE protocols and network architectures.”

Click HERE for an updated list of open positions related to IEC 61850.

More to come.

Saturday, August 17, 2013

Die Energiewende braucht mehr als Messeinrichtungen!

Eine sehr interessante Untersuchung von Ernst & Young im Auftrag des Bundes-Wirtschaftsministeriums kommt zu einer – neu entdeckten – alten Weisheit, die von den vdi-Nachrichten treffend so zusammengefasst und kommentiert wird:

“Ohne die Ausrüstung aller Stromerzeugungsanlagen, die nach dem Erneuerbare-
Energien-Gesetz (EEG) gefördert werden, mit intelligenten Messsystemen [Anmerk. K. Schwarz: gemeint ist die Kombination von Mess- und Steuertechnik] ist die flächendeckende Einführung von Smart Metern in Deutschland volkswirtschaftlicher Unsinn.” Die Investitionen ohne intelligente Steuerungs- UND Regelungsfunktionen (!) wäre mehr als Unsinn!!

Die vdi-Nachrichten führen weiter aus: “Als größtes Hindernis auf dem Weg zu Smart Grids entpuppt sich ausgerechnet das EEG. Dessen Rechtsrahmen gibt in Hinsicht auf intelligente Zähler und digitale Anlagensteuerung nicht viel her und führt in der Praxis eher zurück ins steuerungstechnische Mittelalter.“

Viel mehr gibt es zu diesem Thema fast nicht zu sagen!

Klicken Sie HIER für den Beitrag in den vdi-Nachrichten.
HIER für die BMWI-Pressemeldung (!!).
HIER für die Gesamtstudie von Ernst & Young

In der BMWI-Pressemeldung wird ausgesagt: “Die Bezahlbarkeit von Energie für den Verbraucher ist dabei oberste Leitlinie."

Hat der Schreiber der Aussage mit der Bezahlbarkeit wirklich die Studie gelesen – oder sie nicht verstehen können oder nicht verstehen wollen!?!?

Das wichtigste Ziel muss sein, dass Energie sicher und hoch-verfügbar bereitgestellt wird – sonst gehen die Lichter aus! Vergessen darf man bei alledem auch nicht, das die derzeitige Infrastruktur zum guten Teil in die Jahre gekommen ist und auch noch – zusätzlich zu den intelligenten Systemen – erneuert werden muss!

Erneuerbare Energien und erneuerte Netzinfrastrukturen müssen Hand in Hand gehen! Für beide sind Normen sehr wichtig!

Friday, February 15, 2013

BDEW veröffentlicht Smart-Grid Umsetzungs-Roadmap

Der BDEW (Bundesverband der Energie- und Wasserwirtschaft) hat am 11. Februar 2013 einen Plan veröffentlicht, in dem beschrieben wird, wie und in welchen Schritten sich Smart Grids realisieren lassen:

BDEW-Roadmap:
Realistische Schritte zur Umsetzung von Smart Grids in Deutschland

Die Roadmap kann hier herunter geladen werden [pdf, 3,6 MB].

Der Plan geht davon aus, dass die Umsetzung eher Jahrzehnte dauert als Jahre! Smart Grids werden über einen lang dauernden Marathon erreicht – Sprinter sind fehl am Platz!

In Bezug auf die nächsten zehn Jahre führt die Roadmap in der Executive Summary aus:

“… Das kommende Jahrzehnt wird hierbei in drei Phasen unterteilt:

  • Die Aufbau- und Pionierphase (2012 bis 2014),
  • die Etablierungs- und Ausgestaltungsphase (2014 bis 2018) sowie
  • die Realisierungs- und Marktphase (2018 bis 2022).

Inhaltlich werden zehn Schritte unterschieden: Wichtige Grundlagen für Smart Grids werden durch stringente Regelungen zur Abgrenzung sowie Interaktion von Markt und Netz, die Entwicklung eines konsistenten rechtlichen und regulatorischen Rahmens, Forschung und Entwicklung sowie die Erstellung von Standards und Normen geschaffen. Diese Grundlagen müssen so schnell wie möglich entwickelt werden. Darauf aufbauend soll zum Einen die Weiterentwicklung der Infrastruktur erfolgen (Sensorik, intelligente Messsysteme, Netzautomatisierung, Energieinformationsnetz).”

Ganz wesentliche Grundlagen bezüglich Informations-Bereitstellung, –Modellierung und –Austausch sind mit den Normenreihen bereits definiert und im globalen Einsatz:

  • IEC 60870-5-104 (traditionelle Fernwirktechnik),
  • IEC 61850 (Informationsmanagement für alle Prozesse in der Energieversorgung),
  • IEC 61400-25 (IEC 61850 für Windenergieanlagen),
  • IEC 62351 (Informationssicherheit),
  • IEC 6168/70 (CIM),
  • …

Ein wesentlicher Aspekt bei allen Betrachtungen ist natürlich – kaum überraschend! – die Finanzierung und Rentabilität der Umsetzungen! Bei aller Nüchternheit, die in der Roadmap vorherrscht, wurde ein ganz wesentlicher Aspekt ausgeblendet: Die Notwendigkeit, hinreichend viele Ingenieure und Techniker so auszubilden, dass sie mit den vielen neuen elektrotechnischen (!!) und informationstechnischen (!) Lösungen nachhaltige Versorgungssysteme entwickeln, bauen und nutzen können!

Alleine der Aspekt IEC 61850 ist so umfassend, dass er kaum eben mal nebenbei erlernt und verstanden werden kann. Immer häufiger verstehen die Verantwortlichen in vielen Energieversorgungsunternehmen, dass für die “Kleinigkeit” wie IEC 61850 eine Schulung nachhaltige Vorteile bringt. Nur so können Anbieter und Anwender auf Augenhöhe miteinander verhandeln und zusammenarbeiten. Das habe ich diese Woche wieder während eines Trainings zu IEC 61850 bei einem großen Kraftwerksbetreiber erlebt. Ohne Ausbildung sind die Mitarbeiter (junge, ältere oder auch alte Ingenieure) dem Wohl und Wehe der Anwender ausgeliefert!

Es wäre sehr zielführend, wenn der BDEW die Ausbildung in Richtung IEC 61850 (und anderer Normen) forcieren würde! Vor wenigen Jahren war das Thema IEC 61850 weitgehend tabu!

Thursday, February 14, 2013

IEC 61850 in the Joint EURELECTRIC-EDSO Smart Grid Position Paper

The “Union of the Electricity Industry” (EURELECTRIC) and “European Distribution System Operator for Smart Grids” (EDSO) have assigned a very high priority to the application of IEC TC 57 standards, e.g., IEC 61850, CIM, IEC 60870-5/-6, IEC 62351, … in the paper “DSO PRIORITIES FOR SMART GRID STANDARDISATION”.

End of January 2013 they have published a comprehensive position paper on the standardization for smart grids:

Access the paper “DSO PRIORITIES FOR SMART GRID STANDARDISATION” [pdf, 590 KB]

A key clause puts IEC 61850 on a high priority (excerpt of one example):

3.3. Extended field data modelling standards (IEC 61850) to support demand response, DER and VPP

”While the IEC 61850 standard was originally addressing applications and communications within the substation, recent work is being undertaken for extending its applicability to distribution automation applications integrating field devices located outside the substation fence. With its object oriented structure, IEC 61850 can provide comprehensive and accurate information models for various components of distribution automation systems, as well as an efficient solution for this naturally multi-vendor environment.
Some typical applications include: Volt/Var Control (VVC), Fault Localisation, Isolation and Restoration (FLIR), Outage Management System (OMS), Distribution State Estimator, Distributed Generation and Demand response Management, Load Forecast and Modelling (LFM), and other.
IEC 61850 is the only international standard for substation automation which is open for future application. Currently IEC 61850 is extended for use outside substations. The use cases of the different distribution automation concepts need to be considered in the information data models. Therefore the IEC 61850 data models shall cover all distribution automation objects. IEC 61850 allows an open and flexible design and operation of communication networks. IEC 61850 not only provides a protocol for communication but is a whole new concept for naming and configuring substations and power grids.
The normative definition of logical nodes for DER is necessary for new smart grid appliances because process devices have to be described in such logical nodes for information exchange. Therefore it is important that current valid logical nodes in process protocols are not subject to change in the further standardisation process and to enable new devices to seamlessly comply with existing protocols without proprietary vendor solutions.”

Another key issue is the support of System interoperability operability testing!!

“A system interoperability testing method including conformance testing, "profiles" and "test use cases", should be provided by the end of 2013”

More to come – keep tuned to this blog.

Friday, January 11, 2013

Peak Load Shaving with Batteries – Isn’t that smart?

What does a power system make smart? Smart meters? Hm, … there are many possibilities to make the energy delivery smarter.

One interesting approach is to shave peak load with batteries. I guess this is known for decades! Isn’t it? More and more people are digging into the possibilities to do it in large scales.

A team of researchers has published an interesting paper with the title: “Using Batteries to Reduce the Power Costs of Internet-scale Distributed Networks”. They came to the conclusion that batteries could save up to a third of power costs … you don’t believe it? Read the paper:

Download paper “Using Batteries to Reduce the Power Costs of Internet-scale Distributed Networks”.

IEC 61850 based monitoring and control systems could help to get the job done! The basic tools (embedded controllers with IEC 61850 servers and clients) are available. Let’s use them. Battery models are already defined (and under development) in IEC 61850-7-420. The following is a proposal for battery management for IEC 61850-90-9:

image

More battery related models are underway.